pile of books
skip main nav
 Ling 131: Language & Style
 

 Topic 7 (session A) - The grammar of complex sentences > Linking, listing and nesting clauses > Task D

skip topic navigation
Session Overview
SPOCA Review
Grammar made easy - the basic principles
Linking, listing and nesting clauses
More nesting
Text effects
Linking, listing & nesting checksheet
Complex SPOCA self test
Topic 7 'tool' summary
 
Useful Links
Readings

Linking, listing and nesting clauses

Task D - nesting clauses

To nest one of the sentences inside the other easily, it is easiest if we add a subordinating conjunction at the front of the clause that will become nested (this specifies the used of the nesting semantically). Let's assume that we will nest 'Mary kissed John' inside 'John kissed Mary' to specify a cause-and-effect relation between the two actions. We can do this by putting 'because' at the front of 'Mary kissed John'. Because English is not keen on repeating words too much in complex structures, it will be more natural if we also substitute the pronoun 'him' for 'John' in the clause to be nested.

So, try nesting 'because Mary kissed him' inside 'John kissed Mary'. See how many different places you can make the nesting happen (don't forget that you can nest at the end as well as in the middle of the structure).

Our Answer

We can think of three reasonably natural possibilities. Given the wording of the task, perhaps the most obvious is:

John, because Mary kissed him, kissed Mary.

But you could also get:

Because Mary kissed him, John kissed Mary.

John kissed Mary because Mary kissed him.

Note that in all these cases, the ordering of the kissed is the same, no matter what the ordering in the sentence!

We have use the subordinating conjunction 'because' which indicates a causal connection, but if we had used a different subordinating conjunction (e.g. 'when', 'while', 'if', 'so that' etc) we would have altered the semantic relationship between the clauses (to 'immediately after/at the same moment in time', 'together during a longer stretch of time', and so on).

chuckle stop!

 


to the top
Next: Task E - how does clausal nesting work (i)? next

Home ¦ Outline ¦ Contents ¦ Glossary